Comparing disposable incomes in the UK: Does it motivate energy policy in Northern Ireland?

About

Northern Ireland suffers from persistently lower Gross Disposable Household Income (GDHI) compared to its counterparts. Office for National Statistics (ONS) data reveals a concerning decline in GDHI, particularly in Belfast City Council, indicating an imminent drop into the lowest 15% bracket. This calls for a critical evaluation of energy policies, urging a strategic reinforcement to address the escalating economic challenges.

Abstract

This publication unwraps the complicated terms of UK disposable incomes, spotlighting Northern Ireland's unique economic challenges. With six out of eleven Northern Irish Councils ranking in the bottom 22%, the stark 19% disparity in disposable income compared to the UK average demands urgent attention. The data underscores a critical need for a strategic reassessment of energy policies to effectively address the escalating economic strain and pave the way for a more equitable future.

Summary

  1. Dividing the UK into 12 areas, the Office for National Statistics (ONS) estimate that Gross Disposable Household Income (GDHI) is lower in Northern Ireland, jointly with North East England, than any other UK region. Further subdivision into 179 UK areas shows that 6 of the 11 Councils in Northern Ireland (NI) rank in the bottom 22%, in terms of GDHI.
  2. The statistics also show that, relative to the UK average, GDHI in NI continues to decline, most notably for Belfast City Council, which we predict will, in terms of GDHI per head in the UK, soon be in the lowest 15%. One Council Area, Derry City & Strabane, had the lowest GDHI per head in the UK, of 179 areas, in 2001, and while the situation has slightly improved by 2017, ONS estimate that individuals in this area have almost 30% less disposable income than the UK average. Given these statistics, our view is that energy policy, and the implementation of current policy, should be strengthened.

From bad to worse: disposable income in Northern Ireland is 19% lower than UK average

  1. ONS data published on 22nd May 2019 shows a worsening situation in NI since 2006, relative to other UK regions, and confirms that its residents have had the lowest GDHI for most of the 10-year period ending 2017.

Figure 1: Relative GDHI per head as indices, UK = 100, 12 UK regions, NUTS 1.

145% 135% 125% 115% 105% 95% 85% 75% 1997 2001 2005 2009 2013 2017 London, 143% South East, 116% East of England, 103% South West, 97% Scotland, 93% West Midlands, 87% Yorkshire and The Humber, 83% Northern Ireland 81%

4. It is also clear that there has been a huge GDHI improvement in London, which is driving the overall income equality gap. This should come as no surprise given our other report on inequality worldwide.3 Note also, in contrast to NI, GDHI in Scotland has improve dconsiderably since 1997.

Big city problems: Belfast, Derry and Newry

5. Three cities, and therefore about 35% of the NI population, have lower GDHI per head than the 8 other Councils in NI.

Figure 2: Relative GDHI per head as indices (UK = 100), 11 NI regions (NUTS 3, Councilareas

98% 93% 88% 83% 78% 73% 68% 63% 1997 2001 2005 2009 2013 2017 Belfast, 94% Lisburn and Castlereagh, 93% Ards and North Down, 88% Mid and East Antrim, 88% Antrim and Newtownabbey, 83% Causeway Coast and Glens, 82% Northern Ireland, 81% Armagh City, Banbridge and Craigavon, 79% Belfast, 78% Newry, Mourne and Down, 77% Derry City and Strabane, 73%

6. The most startling observation is the rapid decline in Belfast, which now has the third lowest GDHI per head in NI: a notable decline since 1997 when it had the highest GDHI per head. On this basis, there would be justifiable grounds for policies that target these three areas, and potentially those cities, in particular.

Three NI Councils are in bottom 30 of 179 UK areas

7. The decline in GDHI per head in these three areas, (Belfast, Derry and Newry) can becompared to GDHI per head elsewhere in the UK. Figure 3 below presents the 30 worstregions for GDHI per head, of the 179 areas reported by ONS.

Figure 3: Relative GDHI per head as indices (UK = 100), 30 worst UK regions (NUTS 3)

98% 93% 88% 83% 78% 73% 68% 63% 1997 2001 2005 2009 2013 2017 Belfast, 78% Newry, Mourne and Down, 77% Derry City and Strabane, 73%

8. On this basis, the decline in Belfast appears greater than any other UK region.

Conclusion

9. With disposable incomes between 19% (NI average) and 27% (Derry City and Strabane) lower than the UK average, it is easy to understand that energy policy, and implementation of that policy, should be significantly stronger in comparison.

10. In our view therefore, this evidence justifies a significant re-think by policy makers (eg Department for the Economy), policy implementers (eg Utility Regulator), and other

stakeholders (eg energy retailers such as Power NI and SSE Airtricity in particular) in line with the respective duties of those organisations.

11. The Utility Regulator (UR) should be particularly motived (and justified) to tackle this, for example see UR’s duty as specified at paragraph 12(3) of the Energy (Northern Ireland) Order 2003. Similarly, energy retailers should be under increased scrutiny to comply with existing obligations, for example see SSE’s licence conditions as specified at condition 31 (electricity supply licence) and condition 2.11 (gas supply licence).

12. On these grounds, two related questions arise:

a. Has the UR recently received from each supplier an up-to-date Code of Practice?

b. If so, can each supplier, within a reasonable timeframe, provide the UR with a report outlining its actions over the previous 5 years, alongside a copy of a register of its customers that fall under the provisions of the relevant licence conditions?

Featured resources

No items found.

what’s next

Preview Publication

Want to receive Excel backup data & analysis for this report?

Buy Data

Featured

This paper has been published on following other platforms

No items found.

I was delighted that MCC's work was completed on time, and within budget, helping us deliver important changes and improvements, to the benefit of our stakeholders. ​ MCC's report is published on the CCC website.

- Bea Natzler
Team Leader at Climate Change Committee, UK

I am delighted to recommend MCC Economics. Specifically, I worked closely with PJ, who helped us with our Nuclear and CCUS projects. PJ helped us develop new policies and answer questions from our stakeholders. ​​His support helped us deliver important changes and improvements, to the benefit of our stakeholders.

- Gordon Hutcheson
Head of Nuclear Policy at Ofgem, UK

MCC Economics has helped us better understand the most important issues for our stakeholders, including: charges, shareholder returns, debt payments and inflation impacts.

- Leila N. Nasr
Section Head at Department of Energy, Abu Dhabi

I am delighted to recommend PJ and his team at MCC Economics. We've been working together on National Policy Statements to help meet net zero targets for 2030 and 2050. We initially appointed MCC Economics to support us on offshore wind consultation analysis and have recently reappointed MCC Economics to undertake a larger consultation analysis role across all sectors, including hydrogen, CCUS and networks. I can confirm that PJ and his team have shown excellent spreadsheet skills, alongside very good project management, planning and analysis skills, helping us deliver important changes, and continuous improvements, to the benefit of our stakeholders.

- Amy McHugh
Head of Environment in the Energy Infrastructure Planning Policy, UK

I am delighted to recommend PJ and his team from MCC Economics. They helped us with our price controls for Heathrow airport and for NATS (En Route) plc (the air traffic services provider). Specifically, the MCC team helped us deliver important changes and improvements to our financial models and supporting policy documents, to the benefit of our stakeholders.

- Dan Rock
Head of Corporate Finance at CAA, UK

I am delighted to confirm that I worked with PJ on a retail project in 2015. The project helped stakeholders understand electricity costs and charges. Specifically, the project helped us explain to stakeholders, internally and externally, why electricity charges differed across the regions (GB, NI & Ireland). PJ was a key member on the project team, which helped deliver changes and improvements in the understanding of energy retail.

- Kevin Shiels
Director at Utility Regulator, Northern Ireland